Why Leather Holsters Still Reign Supreme: The Truth About Kydex vs Leather Holsters

Leather Holsters vs Kydex: Comfort, Durability, and Everyday Carry

Discover why leather gun holsters outshine Kydex (plastic) in comfort, durability, aesthetics, and real-world carry for Glock, Sig Sauer, Smith & Wesson, Ruger, and more.

The Disadvantages of Kydex Holsters

  1. Unforgiving comfort: stiff edges against skin, especially IWB. Leather molds to your body.
  2. Noisy draw: plastic clicks vs. leather’s smooth, quiet pull.
  3. Brittle under stress: heat warps, cold can crack. Leather endures.
  4. Finish wear: rigid plastic can scuff firearm finishes; leather cushions the fit.
  5. No soul or style: leather offers craft, tooling, and classic look.
  6. Poor fit for odd/classic models: leather can be shaped for nearly anything.
  7. Doesn’t breathe: sweat buildup vs. leather’s natural breathability.
  8. Hardware dependency: screws/rivets fail; leather relies on strong stitching.

The Advantages of Leather Holsters

  1. Supreme comfort: conforms over time for daily carry.
  2. Quiet and discreet: smooth, silent draws.
  3. Long-term durability: quality leather can last decades.
  4. Protective fit: gentle on finishes across major brands.
  5. Craftsmanship: basket weave, floral tooling, rich dyes.
  6. Reliable retention: firm passive hold with reholster stability.
  7. Versatile styles: IWB, OWB, crossdraw, shoulder, and more.

Popular Models That Shine in Leather

From modern compacts to classic revolvers, leather fits them well: Glock, Sig Sauer, Smith & Wesson, Springfield, Ruger, Taurus, Heritage Rough Rider, Beretta, Walther, FN, Colt, and more.

Final Verdict

Kydex has its place, but for all-day comfort, protection, quiet draws, and timeless style, leather wins.

Ready to upgrade? Explore our Holsters, Western Holsters, Crossdraw Holsters, Suede Leather Holsters, 1911 Holsters, Glock Holsters, and Leather Belts.

Back to blog

1 comment

I just received 2 holsters . 1 Regular Holster (right hand) for a Taurus 627 Tracker with a 6.5" barrel and a “Right Hand Cross Draw” holster for a Smith and Wesson 38 Special (K Frame) with a 6" barrel .
The FIT is EXCELLENT and THEY are BEAUTIFUL !!!! The SHIPPING was SUPER FAST !!! I did ask about the “Fitment” for the 6.5" barrel , They assured Me it would . EXCELLENT COMMUNICATION !!! BOTH HOLSTERS (AGAIN) FIT GREAT and are BEAUTIFUL !!!!!! AWESOME PEOPLE TO DEAL WITH !!!
I am 100% HAPPY !!!!
THANK YOU !!!!
Curtis Estes

Charles Curtis Estes

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.